The Heart of the Debate: Torah Scholars vs. Military Draft

In a vibrant editorial from Yated Ne’eman, an influential publication within the ultra-Orthodox community, long-standing views on the importance of Torah study over military service were eloquently articulated. This opinion piece captured the essence of a perspective held by many within the Haredi sector, emphasizing the irreplaceable role of Torah scholars in ensuring the continuity and integrity of the Jewish people.

Why It Matters: A Cultural and Spiritual Foundation

The discussion surrounding the draft law highlights a fundamental aspect of Israeli societal dynamics – the balancing act between safeguarding national security and preserving sacred religious traditions. Central to the ultra-Orthodox argument is the belief that Torah study is not mere academic pursuit; it is the spiritual lifeline of Judaism. According to Yated Ne’eman, “We need Torah scholars,” reinforcing the idea that dedicated scholars are quintessential to maintaining the spiritual health and continuity of the Jewish community.

The Critique of Secularism and the Defense of Tradition

The piece in Yated Ne’eman also crafts a direct response to what it perceives as the dilution of Jewish values in the chase of a liberal, secularist agenda. Highlighting a critical divide, the editorial contrasts the role of the ultra-Orthodox in preserving Jewish traditions through meticulous study of the Torah with the secular population’s adaptation of modern liberal values. “The secular public is based on liberalism that precisely imitates the depravity of the nations, and assimilates into its own country,” the article notes, advocating for the recognition of Torah study as the most substantial contribution to the Jewish community.

The Essence of the Argument: Torah as the Core of Existence

Yated Ne’eman’s bold stance on the importance of Torah scholarship revolves around the belief that the survival and prosperity of the Jewish people hinge upon its adherence to and reverence for its traditions. The assertion is clear: Torah study transcends the concept of merely acquiring knowledge, serving as a mission of utmost importance. The vitality of the Jewish identity, it contends, is anchored not in military might, but in its unbroken chain of Torah scholars who have been the guardians of its culture and laws throughout history.

Conclusion: A Call for Respect and Understanding

In light of the stout defense of Torah study by the ultra-Orthodox community, the debate on the military draft spotlights deeper issues of identity, faith, and the future direction of Israeli society. As Israel grapples with these complex challenges, fostering an environment of mutual respect and understanding between diverse Jewish sects becomes paramount. Recognizing the unique contributions of each community – be it in the defense forces or in the study halls – is essential for the nation’s unity and spiritual health.

This story was first published on jpost.com.