What it is about:
A recent report by The Guardian alleges that Yossi Cohen, the former head of Israel’s Mossad, engaged in strong attempts to prevent former International Criminal Court (ICC) chief prosecutor Fatou Bensouda from opening a war crimes investigation into Israel, using methods described as “threats and intimidation.”
Why it matters:
The accusations are significant as they touch on how Israel’s intelligence community operates to shield the nation from what it considers biased or unfair investigations. The case points to ongoing tensions between Israel and international institutions and the heavy scrutiny Israel faces globally concerning its defense actions.
Details of the Case:
According to unnamed Israeli and ICC sources, Cohen’s actions were supposedly approved at a high level to act as an “unofficial messenger” for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. One of Cohen’s goals was allegedly ensuring that the ICC would not pursue charges that could diplomatically and legally hinder Israel.
Significant Meetings Highlighted:
The Guardian’s report indicates that Cohen’s interactions with Bensouda began in 2017 at a security conference in Munich. Another crucial encounter occurred in 2018 in New York, where Cohen met Bensouda under conditions described as startling and intimidating
Allegations of Intimidation:
Sources claim Cohen shifted from attempting to establish a rapport to more aggressive measures, which were interpreted as threats. These incidents purportedly included showing photos of Bensouda’s family and insinuating adverse career consequences for the prosecutor.
Official Responses:
In response to inquiries from The Guardian, the Prime Minister’s Office labeled the allegations as “false and unfounded,” aimed at damaging Israel’s reputation. Cohen has not commented on the matter, and Bensouda also declined to give a statement.
Context of Proceedings and Accusations:
Facing serious charges of war crimes, notably during the Gaza conflict of 2014, Israel’s actions were under intense scrutiny. Notably, Bensouda faced historic pressure and biases against Israel amid her probes, a fact Israeli observers consistently highlight. Israel also emphasized possible prosecutorial prejudice that may have influenced timelines of investigations started by Bensouda.
Continuing Investigations under New Leadership:
With Karim Khan’s assumption as the new ICC prosecutor, the controversial case did not diminish but gained renewed momentum particularly following recent hostilities involving Israel and Hamas. Khan has sought arrest warrants for leading Israeli officials, echoing erstwhile aggressive investigative targets originally set by Bensouda.
Comments on Impartial Prosecution and Alleged Intimidation:
While Khan has remained quiet on the specific allegations against Cohen, he affirmed his commitment to prosecuting any infringements aimed at manipulating ICC proceedings. This stance underscores willingness to address any undue influence over international justice systems.
Conclusion:
The accusations reflect underlying, complex interplay between Israel, its intelligence methodologies, and global judicial systems — striving to present a balanced defense narrative amidst prevailing accusations. Amid contentious legal battles and international stalemates, reinforcing truth over strategically leveled charges remains a pivotal undertaking for Israel.
This story was first published on timesofisrael.com.