What is it about
In a year marked by tragedy on Simchat Torah 5784 (October 7, 2023) due to sustained conflict, Jewish communities face a challenge in observing this traditionally joyful holiday. David Golinkin debates how to reconcile the usual celebratory customs with the necessary mourning for the lives lost.
Why it matters
The call to find a balance on Simchat Torah is not just a religious discussion; it is a reflection of resilience and unity among Jewish people. This delicate approach underscores Israel’s commitment to honoring tradition while recognizing the somber realities that have shadowed recent times.
Context and Historical Insights
Simchat Torah is an occasion for joyous celebration of the Torah. However, amidst ongoing conflict and the suffering due to recent attacks, these emotions intertwine with collective mourning. Through history and law, such as the Talmudic passages and customs highlighted by Rabbi Joshua, there is guidance on observing joy while acknowledging sorrow — a balance sought by forebearers, particularly following tragedies like the destruction of the Second Temple.
Proposed Observance Approach for Simchat Torah 5785
Inclusive Prayers and Reflection
Synagogues might incorporate visions like daily recitations not just for joy, but also for remembrance. David Golinkin suggests practices such as adding a Yizkor prayer for the martyrs and war victims, recognizing both historical grieving practices and contemporary contexts.
Adaptation of Traditional Joy
Adjustments to traditional dance practices can symbolically honor the ongoing cost of conflict. Incorporating quiet songs or muted celebrations acknowledges recent sorrow while preserving festival traditions.
Innovative Religious Expressions
Introducing kinnot within the Yizkor services brings in historical lament traditions. Use of such elegies wouldn’t be new; our ancestors regularly remembered Moses’ death at the concluding festive Simchat Torah gatherings, suggesting reflections through kinnot on more recent losses is both appropriate and heartfelt.
The Bottom Line
As Israel stands firm in its rich tapestry of traditions amid collective grief, contemplating observances in light of both devastating and divine laws goes beyond just finding a middle path. It’s a declaration that joy and mourning, celebration, and remembrance can exist in harmony, supporting both communal healing and hopeful resolve.
This story was first published on jpost.com.