What’s happening:
Israel’s current government, led by Benjamin Netanyahu, has faced criticism for its handling of the Gaza conflict, with allegations of intelligence failures and policy misdirection contributing to a strained situation that lacks a clear resolution strategy.
Why it matters:
The consequences of the Israeli government’s approach are becoming increasingly visible, as former high-ranking security officials express concern over the lack of a defined endgame, and international support for Israel begins to waver. This critique extends to the global stage, with US President Joe Biden highlighting the country’s declining public opinion support.
The heart of the issue:
Ami Ayalon and Ephriam Halevy, two prominent figures in Israel’s security establishment, have condemned the government’s excessive reliance on technology over human intelligence, and its failure to heed warnings from female intelligence officers about Hamas’s intentions. Their observations point to an underestimation of Hamas’s capabilities and a preoccupation with annexing the West Bank, leaving Gaza’s defenses weakened.
Key quotes:
Halevy and Ayalon argue that Israel’s current leadership is not transparent about the objectives of the war, and it fails to communicate a vision for the future, post-conflict state of affairs. They advocate for a two-state solution, contrary to the government’s stance.
The bigger picture:
Amidst the ongoing military engagement with Hamas, there is a broader concern about Israel’s long-term strategy and its implications for peace in the region. The government’s current policies are seen as an obstacle to the two-state solution, which is widely supported by international players, including the United States.
The bottom line:
Critics, including former Israeli intelligence chiefs and the US President, suggest that Netanyahu’s leadership is proving to be more of a hindrance than a help in resolving the conflict and securing peace. The growing consensus is that Israel’s approach needs a significant recalibration to align with the goal of a sustainable and peaceful resolution.
This story was first published on jpost.com.