What It’s About
Israel Police have banned the screening of the Palestinian film “Jenin, Jenin 2” at Jaffa’s Al Saraya Theater, deeming it inflammatory. The film is a sequel to the 2002 production, which suggested that the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) massacred civilians during a military campaign in Jenin, allegations widely debunked and condemned.
Why It Matters
The decision underscores the sensitivity surrounding media portrayals of Israeli military actions, particularly those framed around the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The move is also seen as a protective measure, preserving public order by preventing the spread of potentially inciteful content amid ongoing tensions.
The Backdrop
The original 2002 film drew severe criticism not only from Israeli authorities but also from global observers for misleading portrayals and breaches of journalistic integrity. Scenes were manipulated to falsely depict deliberate civilian deaths by the IDF, claims later admitted to be fabricated by director Mohammad Bakri himself.
Controversial Sequel
Directed by the same filmmaker, “Jenin, Jenin 2” follows a 48-hour IDF incursion into Jenin last year, focusing on narratives from those present during the operation. At its crux, it features similar controversial content to the original film and interviews select personnel to continue casting the IDF’s actions in a negative light.
High Court Ruling
Police referenced rulings from the High Court of Justice, which previously barred screenings of the original “Jenin, Jenin,” prioritizing the national interest over sensationalized narratives. These court-guided actions by the police indicate a commitment to holding media products accountable for accuracy and fairness.
Statements and Responses
Theater manager Mahmoud Abu Arisha was interrogated and released with a warning to not show the film, emphasizing adherence to the court’s ruling. He argued that the ban violates freedom of expression, though it aligns with legal precedents aimed at balancing freedom and social responsibility.
Reaction from Bakri
Commentary by Bakri framed the ban as indicative of political suppression under the current government. Such assertions, however, overlook the broader context of ensuring claims made in documentaries are well-grounded and not incendiary.
Proceeds and Future Implications
Previous attempts to screen the sequel, including a halted event by the Israeli Communist Party in Haifa, highlight ongoing efforts to circulate the film. The proceeds were to fund relief in Gaza, a region entwined in the narrative. The monitoring of media portraying sensitive military engagements remains a critical component of national security and truth representation.
The Larger Context
This incident signifies ongoing tensions over historical and contemporary narratives within Israeli society. The careful scrutiny of films like “Jenin, Jenin” reflects a balanced endeavor to mitigate skewed interpretations while allowing rooted grievances to be expressed through appropriate and constructive forums.
This story was first published on timesofisrael.com.