By Hannah Brown, June 30, 2024
What it’s about:
Reuven Fenton, an Orthodox Jewish journalist for the New York Post, explores the dichotomy between Orthodox Judaism and secular American life in his debut fiction novel, “Goyhood.” The story centers on Mayer (formerly Marty) Belkin, a yeshiva student who discovers unsettling truths about his heritage, leading him to grapple with significant questions of faith and identity.
Why it matters:
“Goyhood” is more than a novel; it is an exploration of what it means to be Jewish, blending comedy, drama, and spiritual discourse. It appeals to a broad audience while delving deeply into issues central to Jewish identity, making it a salient piece for Jewish communities and beyond.
Inside the story:
Mayer, a Torah scholar from Brooklyn tied to his roots and community, receives a shocking revelation that his deceased mother was not actually Jewish. While eager to convert and return to his Orthodox life, he is coaxed into a road trip through the South by his secular twin brother, David. The journey forces Mayer to confront his beliefs and the dichotomy between his religious dedication and worldly existence.
A deeper look:
Fenton’s narrative juxtaposes the pious Mayer with the hedonistic David, embodying the struggle between a godly soul and a physical, worldly nature within every individual. Their reconciliation highlights a profound message of balance and unity within the human spirit.
Fenton’s perspective:
Clearly passionate about Jewish thought, Fenton infuses his novel with Talmudic references and spiritual insights, intending “Goyhood” to showcase not just the story but the essence of Jewish learning and faith. His unique experiences enable him to develop characters that resonate with authenticity.
In his own words:
Reflecting on his upbringing, Fenton portrays his transition from a secular Jewish life to Orthodoxy, mirroring Mayer’s struggle through a nuanced portrayal of Jewish life and its inherent confrontations. The story, although fictional, carries truths about self-identity and belonging.
An Israeli-American Connection:
Having reported from Israel post-Oct. 7, Fenton feels at home in Israel despite NYC’s upheaval. “In New York, it’s surreal; a nightmare… In Israel, everyone is carrying the flag,” he says, emphasizing solidarity. His observations enrich the dialogue on American Jewry’s connection to Israel and the Jewish experience worldwide.
The Road Ahead:
Facing challenges in his journalism career with anti-Israel sentiments on college campuses and cultural objections to his work, Fenton stays resilient. “Goyhood” survived industry biases due to his persistence. Writing it has deepened his faith, manifesting as a modern miracle of achieving auteurship against the odds.
The Bigger Picture:
“Goyhood” offers readers more than a narrative; it becomes an educational experience and reflection on Jewish cultural integration and identity. Its success affirms the vibrant and enduring nature of Jewish storytelling and spirit.
This story was first published on jpost.com.