A New Proposal to Resolve the Haredi Draft Crisis

A ground-breaking initiative points towards resolving the Haredi draft issue by recognizing emergency medical technician (EMT) volunteering as a form of national service.

Why It Matters

The proposal offers a balanced solution aiming to integrate Haredi men into Israel’s national service framework while respecting their religious lifestyle. By doing so, it addresses the long-standing debate on the inclusion of ultra-Orthodox men in Israel’s security apparatus.

The Drive Behind the Proposal

Eli Beer, President and Founder of United Hatzalah, suggests instituting a mandatory national civil service for ultra-Orthodox men. This would involve a 2-3 year commitment to civil organizations like United Hatzalah, where they would serve as EMTs and paramedics trained to carry firearms.

A Critical Decision from Israel’s High Court

Israel’s High Court of Justice recently ruled that the government must draft ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students into the IDF, specifying there is no “legal framework” for exempting them. This decision underscores the urgent need for increased security manpower in Israel.

A History of Contribution

Haredi men have historically avoided IDF enlistment to preserve their Torah-focused lifestyle. However, many are open to serving in capacities that align with their religious practices. Following the October 7th Hamas attack, there’s been a notable increase in Haredi enlistment.

An Effective Framework: United Hatzalah

Established 35 years ago with Haredi volunteers, United Hatzalah has demonstrated the effectiveness of integrating religious men into vital societal roles. Haredi volunteers often commit long-term, serving the community while adhering to their religious principles.

Unity for a Stronger Israel

Beer stresses the importance of national unity, particularly after the October 7th Hamas massacre. Integrating the Haredi population through civil service organizations like United Hatzalah can help bridge societal divides and strengthen Israel’s security and community resilience.

The Path Forward

United Hatzalah’s model shows promise for easing the government’s burden by providing a viable alternative to military service that still contributes significantly to national security and emergency response. This proposal exemplifies the potential for innovative solutions to national challenges.

This story was first published on jpost.com.