What it’s about
The Tel Aviv-Jaffa District Court has approved Communications Minister Shlomo Karhi’s request to extend the temporary ban on the Al Jazeera news network in Israel for an additional 45 days. This order affects both Al Jazeera’s broadcasts and its website.
Why it matters
This decision underscores Israel’s ongoing security concerns associated with Al Jazeera’s content and its alleged connections with Hamas. The action highlights Israel’s commitment to national security, particularly concerning media influences that may encourage terrorism.
The court’s findings
The court concluded that there is a direct link between Al Jazeera content and individuals involved in terror attacks within Israel. The investigation revealed that some reporters for Al Jazeera in Gaza had overstepped journalistic bounds, allegedly becoming “assistants and partners” with Hamas, with some even reportedly participating in terror activities.
Statements from the judge
Deputy President of the Tel Aviv-Jaffa District Court, Judge Haggai Brenner, emphasized the severity of the findings. “Classified material demonstrated the close connection between Hamas and certain Al Jazeera reporters,” said Brenner. Additionally, evidence suggested that Al Jazeera serves as a “public diplomacy and intelligence arm” for Hamas.
Brenner remarked on the influence Al Jazeera’s broadcasts have on certain population groups in Israel, citing them as motivators for terrorist activities. “There is a proven causal relationship between the content Al Jazeera broadcasts and the terror attacks carried out,” he added.
Background and implications
Al Jazeera’s broadcasts were first halted on May 5 based on an emergency law enacted in April. The law allows foreign media outlets, considered a threat to national security, to be temporarily blocked. Approvals require the prime minister and the security cabinet’s agreement on recommendations from a security agency.
This case is unique as Al Jazeera is the only outlet affected thus far. The current law, which could be extended, is set to expire on July 31. The emergency law is currently facing a challenge in the High Court of Justice by the Association for Civil Rights in Israel, questioning its impact on free speech and press freedom.
The High Court’s involvement
The High Court has issued a conditional order demanding an explanation from the government regarding the law’s constitutionality. Justice Isaac Amit indicated the complexity of the law, necessitating a broader review by an expanded panel of justices.
This story was first published on timesofisrael.com.